Homemade Toffee Sampler Boxes Make a Sweet Gift for any Occasion. 

Some gifts just feel like Christmas. A tin of homemade toffee, buttery and golden, packed with crunchy almonds, the kind that used to sit on Grandma's counter and disappear by New Year's. Now that old-fashioned treat comes in our Four Flavor and Six Flavor Toffee Sampler Gift Boxes, ready to ship to anyone on your list. Send one for Christmas, a birthday, a thank-you, or a simple "I'm thinking of you." Or keep one for yourself and taste your way through every flavor. You've earned it.

Both sizes of the Homemade Toffee Sampler Gift Boxes come in a resealable container with a seasonal bow for easy gifting. No wrapping required. 

What Flavors of Toffee Come in Each Gift Box

• The Small, 4 Flavor Toffee Sampler Includes

  • Butterscotch: Butter, sugar, water, almonds, butterscotch

  • Milk Chocolate: Butter, sugar, water, almonds, milk chocolate

  • White Chocolate: Butter, sugar, water, almonds, white chocolate

  • Peanut Butter: Butter, sugar, water, almonds, peanut butter

• The Large, 6 Flavor Toffee Sampler Includes

  • Butterscotch: Butter, sugar, water, almonds, butterscotch

  • Coffee: Butter, sugar, water, almonds, chocolate, coffee

• • Dark Chocolate: Butter, sugar, water, almonds, dark chocolate

  • Milk Chocolate: Butter, sugar, water, almonds, milk chocolate

  • White Chocolate: Butter, sugar, water, almonds, white chocolate

  • Peanut Butter: Butter, sugar, water, almonds, peanut butter

Give the Gift of Homemade Goodness Like Grandma Used to Make

Product Specifications

• Each batch is handmade fresh when you order, giving you the delicious taste and satisfying crunch you remember from old-fashioned homemade candy. 

• Toffee flavors can not be changed in either size box.

• Gift boxes come with a seasonal bow of the manufacturer's choice. Those shown in the pictures are for display only and may not be available. 

• Allergy Alert: All flavors of our toffee includes Almonds. Peanut Butter Toffee contains peanut butter.

• Made in the USA in Alabama, where each batch of Molly's toffee is handmade fresh when ordered for the buttery crunch and old-fashioned character of homemade candy.

• Please Note: This product ships directly from the manufacturer and is not eligible for Harvest Array free shipping on orders over $75.00.

• Because this Toffee is made and shipped from Alabama, It can only be shipped if the  temperature is below 78 degrees F, as the chocolate will melt. 

A Sweet Gift for Any Occasion

Homemade candy has a way of making people smile. Share a box with family and friends, bring it along to a holiday gathering, or keep a little for yourself. It’s a delicious reminder that sometimes the simplest treats are the ones we remember most.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Is this toffee really homemade?

A: Yes! The toffee is handcrafted fresh when you order, giving it the nostalgic taste and texture of homemade candy.

Q: What is homemade toffee made with?

A: The basic toffee varieties are made with butter, sugar, water, and almonds. Depending on the flavor, chocolate, coffee, butterscotch, or peanut butter is added.

Q: What flavors of homemade toffee come in the small sampler gift box?

A: Four flavors of toffee come in the small box. They are: Butterscotch, Milk Chocolate, White Chocolate, and Peanut Butter

Q: What flavors of homemade toffee come in the large sampler gift box?

A: Six flavors of toffee come in the large toffee sampler box. They are: Butterscotch, Coffee, Dark Chocolate, Milk Chocolate, White Chocolate, and Peanut Butter.

Q: Can I change the toffee flavors in the Sampler Gift Boxes if I know I don't like one of them?

A: No. The Four Toffee Flavor and Six Toffee Flavor Sampler Gift Boxes can not be changed. Find our individual homemade toffee flavor 1/2 pound and 1 pound boxes Here.

Q: Where is this toffee made?

A: This toffee is made in Alabama, USA.

Q: Is Homemade Toffee good for gift giving?

A: Absolutely! A Sampler box of old-fashioned homemade toffee makes a thoughtful gift for holidays, birthdays, thank-you gifts, hostess gifts, or simply sharing with someone special. The recipient gets a taste of all of our most popular flavors. The containers come wrapped with a seasonal style bow, so no gift wrapping required. 

Q: Can I choose the color bow I want?

A: No, it's up to the manufacturer what type of seasonal bow she has in stock at the time of your order.

Q: Does the toffee contain nuts?

A: Yes. All of the listed varieties contain almonds. Please review the ingredient list for your chosen sampler before ordering.

Q: How should I store homemade toffee?

A: For the best texture and flavor, store your toffee in a cool, dry place away from heat and moisture. Keep it well sealed when not being enjoyed.

Q: Can I use this toffee for holiday candy trays?

A: Definitely! The Homemade Toffee Sampler Gift Boxes make the holidays simple and stress-free! Our four or six toffee flavor sampler trays can be used as a holiday candy tray itself! Order several from Harvest Array for when your holiday social calendar fills up.  Place the container of toffee right on a Christmas Party dessert table, take one to a cookie exchange or family gathering, we won't tell that you didn't make it!

Q: Does this product qualify for Harvest Array's free shipping offer?

A: No. Because this product ships directly from the manufacturer, it is not eligible for free shipping on Harvest Array.